Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. (NIC)

Financial Services · Banks - Regional · Mid-cap · updated October 16, 2026

NOT A BUY TODAY

What this means. Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. is an average business by our measures, its shares look expensive compared with other stocks, and its share price has been doing well.

Value35

Quality44

Price trend66

Overall44

2036 of 2764rank among the US stocks we score (our core model buys the top 15)

26%of US stocks we score rank below it

Scores are 0 to 100 against every US stock we track; 50 is average. Recomputed after every US market close.

The business in numbers

Fiscal year to December 2025, from the company's annual filing with the SEC.

Return on equityprofit vs. shareholders' accounting value	12.0%
Debt / equitydebt vs. shareholders' accounting value	0.11
Change in share countnegative = the company is buying back its shares	-0.1%

Insider trades, last 90 days

2 insiders sold $716K on the open market.

Witczak Eric JamesEVP - Retail & Ag Banking	SoldJul 28	342 shat $171.96 · $59K
Witczak Eric JamesEVP - Retail & Ag Banking	SoldJul 27	1,215 shat $167.89 · $204K
Atwell Robert BruceDirector	SoldJul 24	2,662 shat $170.24 · $453K

From Form 4 filings with the SEC. Open-market trades only. "Plan" = a sale set up in advance under a 10b5-1 plan, usually routine.

Higher-scoring in the same industry

CARE Carter Bankshares, Inc.overall 69 · rank 60
BMRC Bank of Marin Bancorpoverall 67 · rank 119
PCB PCB Bancorpoverall 66 · rank 124
CFFI C&F Financial Corporationoverall 66 · rank 146
NECB Northeast Community Bancorp, Inc.overall 65 · rank 170

Interactive lookup Get the Ledger every Monday

Not financial advice. Research and education only: the same view for everyone, with no regard to your circumstances. Past results do not predict future ones. Decide for yourself or with a licensed adviser. Terms · Privacy